PostingSchool for thought

"What about trying this place," suggests Va-vay, as we debate a school for our two-year-old daughter Beanie.

Though he would never admit as much, Va-vay is basing this idea on Alexander McCall Smith's 44 Scotland Street novels, whose young hero Bertie is forced to attend the same institution. I cannot help thinking that Va-vay has slightly missed the point here: Bertie is miserable at being made to go to school there. But at twenty five weeks pregnant, I choose my battles carefully.

The next day I call the school.

"Allo, yes?" says a Germanic accent on the other end of the phone that sounds like a parody of itself.

"Err, hello, could you put me through to your admissions secretary?"

Silence. No farewell niceties, just a click on the line. Another voice answers.

"Hello. What can I do for you?" I feel like I've broken a rule by knocking on the staffroom door at lunch break and she's torn herself away from a sandwich to see me.

I explain I am looking for a school for my young daughter. My voice is cracking up slightly and I swallow nervously.

"Very good. I'll put a copy of our prospectus in the post. And we have a tour of the school on 1 May for prospective parents. Can you attend that?"

"Yes, I think so. Let me just check my diary," I reply, feeling slightly crushed, as if I haven't done my homework on time or forgot to wash my PE kit for games. "Yes, that should be fine."

"I will put your name down then. Will your husband be with you?"

I haven't mentioned a husband. How does she know I'm married? Is this how they go about 'nurturing the imagination' and fostering 'keen thinking and questioning skills' as promised on their website - jumping to conclusions about people's private lives?

"No, he won't be," I explain, feeling inexplicably nervous. "But I'd like to bring my daughter along, to show her the place. See her response."

"That won't be possible," says Madam, sounding ticked off. "We don't permit young children to come on tours. They're too disruptive."

I force myself to state the obvious. "But it's my daughter who would be at the school. I need to see how she takes to it." Or not, I think, silently.

"No, children are not allowed. We take tours into classrooms and young children of her age would disturb pupils who are working."

I remember that these people are proposing to charge us many thousands of pounds for educating Beanie. A flame of anger jumps up in me.

"Oh, okay. I see. Well, look, I think in that case we might just leave it then, thanks all the same. This isn't really what we're looking for."

I hear a click on the other end of the phone and the line goes dead. Even these people haven't had the cheek to suggest they'll be teaching pupils much in the way of social skills.

Later that day I recount the experience to Beanie's granny, a former teacher.

"Why is it that so many people in teaching don't actually seem to like children very much?" I ask her. "Don't they know they'll be with children all day long if they go into teaching?"

Granny just shrugs. "Don't know. Some people go into it because they want to reform children. It gives them a moral uplift. There's a power dynamic there, you know."

Even if it turned out Beanie adored the place, I wouldn't want to set foot in it.

Posted 27 March 2008 15:56

Edinburgh Granny

Comments

Rosie said:

Oh no - not the whole choosing school drama. I've just finished that one myself. IJ started local our school in January, I was reasonably happy with the school although to be completely honest I did not do my research well enough. It was not until the Ofsted report came out that I discovered there were some HUGE problems.



Consequently I've uprooted IJ and she starts at a brand new school on Monday. It's an excellent school, IJ loves it and many of her friends go there. I have no concerns at all although the whole experience has been very stressful.



So my advice - visit all potential schools without Beanie, then visit with Beanie if they pass the test, look at prospectus', talk to the teachers, consider the secondary schools they feed into, consider the views of Ofsted, and trust your instincts!



That said, don't stress about it too much, starting school is supposed to be an exciting experience (at least for the children!)

Posted 27 March 2008 21:43

iota said:

I always feel woefully out of my depth when visiting preschools/nurseries/schools. They all say the right things in their literature, and when you're given the tour, it all looks good. I think it's very hard to get a realistic impression of a place on the basis of an hour's visit. You inevitably end up making big judgments on the basis of small details. For me, it's another of those "muddle through" aspects of parenthood.



But other parents seem to have stronger instincts, so I don't want to sound all gloom and doom as you embark on the process.

Posted 27 March 2008 23:41

Vanessa said:

M's school is lovely and they have an open day on a Sautrday in October where you're invited to take children along. If you want to arrange an individual tour, it might be best not to take her along just so that you're not distracted from the questions you might want to ask and the aspects of the school that you are especially interested.

Posted 28 March 2008 10:59

Helen said:

Hi Rosie, yes, gut instincts tell us the most, don't they. But it's so easy to get distracted by other things. Glad IJ has a school where she's happy and can settle.



Hi Iota, if we can muddle through with somewhere Beanie's happy I'll be very content.



Hi Vanessa, is funny you should say that as I called them after this place, and they sounded normal, friendly and reasonably. It's not too much to ask, is it.

Posted 28 March 2008 19:07

Erica said:

All sounds a bit business like :(

Posted 28 March 2008 21:34

Helen said:

Hi Erica, didn't seem quite right to me. But who am I to judge these things.

Posted 28 March 2008 22:00

DJ Kirkby said:

OMG! That school sounds horrible! OMG! OMG! Runaway!

Posted 31 March 2008 06:45

Helen said:

DJ, am under the wire and running, hoping the search lights and tracker dogs won't find me.

Posted 31 March 2008 14:11

zornhau said:

I think it's the reverse of those nurseries with animals painted on the windows, but with the text readable from the outside, and just as bad.



You want to be neither wooed by carefully staged appearences, nor treated as if you should think yourself lucky if your child gets in.



Since you live in a nice area, you might want to take a good look at the local state school, which has the advantage of being free. Given the political and economic climate, if you do have the spare for school fees, might it not be better redirected to a college fund?

Posted 01 April 2008 22:57

Helen said:

Zornhau, so many private Edinburgh schools are insufferably smug. And I should know; I went to one myself.

Posted 02 April 2008 15:18

Julie said:

Although that does sound hideous, and very off putting I did visit a school I wanted my older child to go to with an 18 month old. He couldn't stay in the buggy as there were lots of stairs and I couldn't concentrate at all, O agree with first poster - Go once on your own and then if they pass the test, take beanie back the second time. Most schools have more than one open day anyway.

Posted 04 April 2008 14:18

Helen said:

Oh, Julie, you are probably right. The pregnancy hormones are making me too sensitive. It was more an overall impression that the children were a necessary evil that had to be tolerated for the school to get its hands on our fees. Oh, and that we would be made to feel bad for not surviving on knitted yoghurt and tofu.

Posted 04 April 2008 18:26


Post a comment

Enter your comment here.

You can use some html tags such as <b> and <i>.

Word verification

Name

Email (will not be made public)

Website (optional)

Remember me